“For whoever is not against us is with us.” Mark 9:40
” Whoever is not with me is against me, and whoever does not gather with me scatters.” Mathew 12:30
Anyone else see the contradiction?
This past Sunday I heard the parable about the apostles of Jesus Christ trying to stop a person – whom they did not consider one of them – from casting out demons in the name of Jesus. Jesus rebukes them saying if a person is not against him then he belongs (Mark 9:40). It speaks of “an inclusive welcoming church”, one that reminds me of the progressive liberal period with Pope John Paul II as the head. I immediately thought of how I sometimes feel that this different from where the church is heading under Pope Benedict XVI.
But, then one can also find a Bible quote to support what some see as the different “unequivocal you must toe this line or else” voice of the church under the current Pope, Benedict XVI. In the gospel of Mathew, the Pharisees state that since Jesus cured a demoniac he must be an agent of the Devil. Jesus rebukes them and warns them that one cannot remain neutral. You have to be either for or against him (Mark:12:30).
It is easy to find Bible quotes that support a point of view of the Catholic Church one thinks one wants.
In the parable of seeking to exclude in Mark’s gospel there is an ambivalence associated with the demon caster, but in the gospel of Mathew we have Jesus responding to those who are bitterly opposed to him. In the first he speaks of growing the church; in the second of the divisions within, saying, “Every kingdom divided against itself will be laid to waste, and no town or house divided against itself will stand (Mathew 12:25).”
As in the Bible, both responses of Popes John Paul II and Benedict XVI are to what they see as the context of the situation, and are not necessarily about “me”. It is not about the church being for/with/against “me” – it is God’s Church. Through both stories run what I see as a common thread: Jesus and Love. And after all isn’t that what it is all about?
All too of often we respond to our situations and lives from just a “me” perspective. We respond divisively. I pray that we have the grace to understand the greatest gift of all: the relational nature of LOVE. After all, the Christian Creation story is that at the beginning God created man and woman – not man, or woman.*
*I can further explore the relational nature of love through the dogma of the trinity – three persons in one God – that is part of the Catholic Church Catechism. If you are interested you can start by quickly skimming the introductory paragraphs in wikipedia’s entry on the Trinity.